Christian Zacharias, Orchestre de Chambre de Lausann - Mozart : Piano Concertos Vol 4 (2009) [SACD]

AllMusic:
This disc is part of a Mozart concerto cycle being issued by German pianist Christian Zacharias, conducting the Chamber Orchestra of Lausanne. Several of the discs have been exceptional, & the musicianship here maintains the high level of the earlier releases in the series. The interpretations, however, are a bit unorthodox, so sample well & consider. The audiophile sound from the MDG label continues to be an attraction in itself; the sonics of Lausanne’s moderate-sized & heavily acoustically tweaked Salle Métropole concert hall have awesome clarity & depth. The contrast between MDG’s approach — it seeks out halls that are musically & historically appropriate — & those of engineers who simply choose the most acoustically live church in the immediate area could not be clearer & could not reflect better on this small German label. Zacharias has favored a liquid but clean sound with very little pedal, generally quite restrained but leaving room for little outbursts of expression as a movement coalesces into formal clarity. In these 2 sharply contrasting concertos, he may be too restrained for some listeners. The Piano Concerto #19 in F major, K. 459, following a long Austrian tradition going back through such pianists as Ingrid Haebler, often has an ebullient pastoralism, with plenty of vigor in its marchlike opening (suggested perhaps by Mozart’s notation that the work featured trumpet & drum parts, perhaps lost or perhaps never written in the 1st place) & an emphasis on the polyphony that playfully rises out of the light thematic material in the finale. Far from having the (modern grand) piano stand up to the rhythmic vitality, Zacharias tamps everything down. The result is a very subtly humorous treatment that stands out from other recordings on the market but is certainly subject to debate (not least in the added cadenza partway through the finale). The big Piano Concerto in D minor, K. 466, is similar. Zacharias avoids Beethovenian mannerisms, with a rather flat opening of the usually restless opening of the finale. The tension is seemingly transferred to the central Romanze, which he takes at a quick clip & in which he pushes the tempo of the seemingly limpid main theme. Zacharias’ facility with the details of the long Mozartian concerto movement is especially clearly in evidence here: the opening movement builds in every way toward an intense climax. As distinctive as other releases in the series, this 1 is just a bit less orthodox.